Finding the Best Florida Car Insurance Rates for 2024

With the new year approaching, many Florida drivers will be shopping around for car insurance in order to get the lowest rates possible in 2024. Choosing the right auto insurance policy can save you a lot of dollars each year. 


How Car Insurance Rates Are Determined in Florida

Before exploring specific insurance companies and rates, it’s crucial to grasp the key components that influence auto premium pricing in Florida. Insurance companies analyze many data points about each customer in order to calculate their individual risk level and set an appropriate rate. The top factors looked at include:

Driving Record

Having a clean driving history without any moving violations, accidents, or claims is extremely important for getting low car insurance rates. Even minor tickets like speeding can cause premiums to increase significantly. Insurance companies will look back several years to examine a driver’s full record. The longer the clean driving time, the better the rates will be.

Credit History

Insurers believe that people with good credit are less likely to file fraudulent claims. All major providers in Florida are allowed to use credit-based insurance scores in their underwriting and pricing procedures. While not a direct factor, maintaining a high credit score can qualify customers for lower rates.


Vehicle Type and Features

More expensive vehicles to insure include luxury brands and sports cars. Insuring a basic sedan will result in much cheaper premiums than a high-performance model. Additional features like full-coverage security systems may provide discounts. The age of the vehicle is also considered, with newer cars costing more to insure on average.

Location and Demographics

Where a person lives and drives affects their auto rates greatly. Urban areas with more traffic and higher claims costs mean higher base rates. Neighborhood crime statistics are another location metric examined. Demographic factors like credit scores, marital status, and years of license also play indirect roles via statistical analysis of risk.

Coverage Limits and Deductibles

Drivers have control over choosing their coverage levels and out-of-pocket costs on claims. Opting for lower liability limits, higher deductibles, or removing optional protections like rental reimbursement can all help decrease insurance costs significantly. However, it’s important not to skimp on necessary protection.

Discounts and Surcharges

Insurers provide many ways for customers to save, such as multi-policy discounts, good student grades, defensive driving courses, and anti-theft devices. Customers may also face surcharges like higher rates for teenage drivers or DUIs on their records long after the violation occurred. Understanding available discounts is key to lowering premiums.

How to Compare Florida Car Insurance Quotes

With so many variables dictating pricing, the only way to find the truly lowest rates is to get customized quotes from multiple insurers. Here is a step-by-step guide for comparing auto insurance options in Florida:

Gather Documentation

Have your driver’s license, vehicle information like VIN and garaging address, current coverage limits if switching insurers, and insurance score if available on hand when applying for quotes.

Select 3 to 5 Insurers

We will review the top providers in Florida later, but in general, we aim to get quotes from a mix of large national companies plus local insurers for the most competitive options.

Complete Online Forms

Nearly all insurers let you start the quoting process online in just 5-10 minutes by filling out basic info. Some may need a call for additional details, depending on your history.

Compare Apples-to-Apples

Ensure the same or similar coverage levels are quoted to make an accurate comparison. Tailor coverages as needed once you find the best base rate.

Inquire About Discounts

Ask about all available ways to save on top of just the rates quoted initially, like bundling, good grades, affiliations, and more. A few eligibility questions can save hundreds of premiums.

Consider the Full Package

Weigh in great customer service, financial strength of the insurer, and extra policy perks versus a slightly lower premium. Rates shift often, so re-shop annually or if your driving profile changes.

By taking the time to methodically work through this process, drivers will discover their true lowest potential rate for high-quality Florida auto insurance protection. Now, let’s explore specific insurer options in the state.

Top Florida Car Insurance Providers to Consider

There are many choices when shopping for an auto insurance policy in Florida. Below are brief reviews of several industry-leading companies that consistently offer competitive rates statewide:


As one of the largest auto insurers nationwide with a huge market presence in Florida, GEICO frequently has the absolute cheapest rates quoted and has highly developed online quoting tools. Their focus on low prices and no-hassle claims sometimes leads to limited customizability and service levels for more complex policies, however.


For over 75 years, Progressive has been providing excellent coverage across 45 states, including Florida. Their reputation as an industry disrupter with creative policies and 24/7 virtual services generally leads to middle-of-the-road prices. Customers appreciate simple online accounts and optional add-ons like usage-based programs.

State Farm

Being the top seller of auto insurance in America for over 90 years is a testament to State Farm’s commitment to reliability and customer satisfaction above all else. Agencies throughout Florida stand by with local expertise to create fully tailored coverage for many diverse driving needs, though premiums can skew higher on average.


As another very large national brand, Allstate is ubiquitous in Florida with competitive standard auto rates. Beyond insurance, they focus heavily on total home and lifestyle protection solutions, which may appeal to some. High-net-worth customers often turn to Allstate for exclusive types of high-liability coverage as well.


Exclusive to active military members, veterans, and their families, USAA is consistently ranked at the very top for customer service and satisfaction. Their niche focus results in some of the industry’s most competitive auto quotes for eligible members, though most Florida drivers cannot access this insurer directly.

Liberty Mutual

With over 100 years in business across the globe, Liberty Mutual brings financial strength and nationwide coverage areas. Independent agents tailor policies to drivers’ unique situations fairly and transparently. While not always the absolute lowest-priced, the reputation for claims handling is strong, and the service is very customizable.

These represent some of the most popular players in the large, competitive Florida auto insurance market. Be sure to also explore highly rated regional insurers like Universal Property and Casualty or Southern Farm Bureau to discover potential niche fits. The best choice varies per individual’s profile and priorities.

Ins and Outs of Florida Auto Insurance Coverage Levels

At a basic level, all Florida motorists are required by state law to carry Bodily Injury and Property Damage levels of at least $10,000 per person/$20,000 per accident and $10,000 in property damage liability per accident. However, drivers can customize their protection levels and add significant optional coverage via these major types:

Bodily Injury Liability

Covers medical bills and compensation for injuries sustained by other parties in an at-fault accident you cause. Increasing limits to $100,000/$300,000 or $250,000/$500,000 is recommended for significant asset protection if sued.

Property Damage Liability

Pays for repairs to other vehicles or property damaged in an accident you cause. $50,000 in coverage strikes a fair balance between cost and protection level. More may be needed if driving larger commercial vehicles.

Personal Injury Protection (PIP)

Florida’s no-fault coverage provides up to $10,000 for medical bills and lost wages resulting from auto accidents, regardless of fault. Drivers may waive this with signed exemptions.

Collision Deductible

Pays for repairs to your own vehicle resulting from collision damage like hitting another car or object. Choose a deductible between $250-$1,000 based on budget. Higher is cheaper, but you pay more per incident out-of-pocket.

Comprehensive Deductible

Similar to collision, it covers non-collision risks like weather, falling objects, wildlife strikes, theft, or falling. Deductibles and coverage amounts are again customizable based on your vehicles and needs.

Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist

Required if wanting Bodily Injury coverage, this pays for your injuries and lost wages if another at-fault uninsured/underinsured driver causes an accident. Maintain limits matching your BI levels.

Other Common Add-Ons

Such as medical payments for others injured while in your vehicle, rental reimbursement, rideshare coverage, towing/labor, gap insurance if owing more than vehicle is worth, and more. Evaluate each need on a case-by-case basis.

Proper coverage limits today give peace of mind that you and your assets are sufficiently insured no matter the unforeseen circumstances ahead on Florida roads. Adjust levels annually as needed based on inflation, changing property values, or vehicles.

How to Lower Your Florida Car Insurance Rates

While having adequate insurance coverage is important, the cost of premiums is also a major factor for many drivers. Thankfully, there are proactive steps Florida motorists can take to reduce what they pay for auto insurance:

Maintain a Clean Driving Record

As one of the top determinants of rates, keeping your record violation- and incident-free is key. Drive carefully and defensively to avoid tickets, accidents, or claims for at least 3-5 years if possible.

Improve Your Credit Score

Most insurers use credit-based insurance scores in Florida, so maintain yours above 700 if able. Pay bills on time to see reduced rates over time from many companies.

Take Defensive Driving Courses

Many insurers provide multi-percentage point discounts for completing maturity courses available around the state. This also improves driving habits long-term.

Install Anti-Theft Devices

Adding certified security systems can earn you savings of 5-10% off comprehensive coverage from insurers recognizing the lower risk of auto theft claims.

Increase Your Deductibles

Opting for higher out-of-pocket costs on small claims like $500-1000 deductibles will significantly decrease premium costs, paying for itself if no losses occur.

Bundle Home & Auto Policies

Getting quotes for insuring both your residence and vehicle(s) with the same company earns multi-line discounts, often around 10-15% total savings.

Ask About Other Discounts

Inquire about each renewal or application and about additional ways to save, like good student status, alarm system maintenance training, and affiliation group rates.

Proactively managing your insurance program through prudent financial habits and driving practices is the easiest method to lower Florida auto insurance premiums year after year. Contact your agent or carriers directly about available savings opportunities, too.

Back to top button